Blog

Black Friday's Hidden Tax: The True Cost of OTP Authentication

Discover the hidden costs of OTP authentication during Black Friday. From rising SMS expenses and checkout friction to fraud risks, and learn how unified authentication can reduce them.

Published: November 19, 2026
Chris Dermody
Learn More about the author: Black Friday's Hidden Tax: The True Cost of OTP Authentication
Share:

Key takeaways

  • Measure the full cost of authentication: Every SMS code, retry, and failed attempt can increase expenses during peak shopping periods.
  • Find where customers get stuck: Repeated challenges can interrupt legitimate customers at critical moments.
  • Review the paths around login: One-time passcodes remain vulnerable to phishing, social engineering, and interception.
  • Start with one journey: Recognizing trusted customers and applying risk-based step-ups can reduce unnecessary challenges.

‍

Black Friday brings more shoppers, more transactions and more verification codes. A bigger SMS bill doesn’t necessarily mean more customers are getting through safely. Some codes are retries, some interrupt customers and others are triggered by attackers who have no intention of buying anything. 


For fraud, risk, and digital experience leaders, the opportunity is to identify which challenges establish trust and which simply add cost.

Before peak traffic arrives, ask: How many OTPs do we actually need to send?

Take the Prove OTP Assessment → 

According to Adobe Analytics, U.S. consumers spent $44.2 billion online during Cyber Week 2025. Cyber Monday alone generated $14.25 billion, while Black Friday contributed $11.8 billion.

For retailers, marketplaces, payment providers, and banks, more holiday shoppers mean more chances to win business. Logging in, creating an account, or making a purchase can trigger another text. Every code costs money, every resend adds to the bill, and every extra step gives customers another reason to abandon the flow.

Businesses have grown used to paying for OTPs. But those costs don’t always buy better security or experience. A stronger approach is recognizing trusted customers in the background and asking for extra verification when it’s needed. Making the customer authentication experience flow safely and easily, that’s what a unified authentication solution can enable.

‍

The Three Hidden Costs of OTP Dependence

1. Direct Costs: What Does a Completed Authentication Really Cost?

SMS authentication is a variable expense. As transaction volumes increase, so can messaging fees, retries, and operational costs.

Consider a business processing 10 million authentication journeys per month. If each journey generates an average of 1.3 OTPs at a blended delivery cost of $0.05, direct messaging expenses reach $650,000 per month, or $7.8 million annually. 

That's an illustrative calculation, not an industry benchmark. Actual pricing varies, and the example excludes platform fees, support costs, fraud investigations, and lost transactions. 

The more useful question is: What are you spending to get one legit customer through authentication? 

Look beyond the price per text. Track cost per completed authentication, messages per journey, and completion rate to see where retries and failures drive up costs.

More code requests don’t always mean more customers. SMS pumping attacks trigger paid messages without legitimate shopping activity. If requests rise while completions fall, investigate unusual patterns.

Review rate limits, resend delays and geographic controls and identify where trusted customers could authenticate without another code.

2. Customer Experience: Find the Step That Loses the Customer

We’ve all waited for a verification code, requested another, or switched between apps to retrieve it. Your customers experience those interruptions as part of shopping with you.

To improve that experience, measure the authentication step itself:

  • How many customers reach the challenge and complete it?
  • How long does completion take?
  • How often do customers request another code or seek help?

Look for opportunities to recognize trusted customers without making them enter another code, and require extra validation when risk warrants it.

The goal is to give customers the security and ease you’d want for yourself and use evidence to decide when another challenge is necessary.

3. Fraud Exposure: Protect the Routes Around Login

Reducing routine OTP use is only part of the solution. Teams also need to determine what happens when the preferred authentication method fails. 

A customer may use a passkey at login but rely on an SMS code to recover access. Others may change their phone number, enroll a new device or contact support for help. 

Those paths deserve the same attention as the front door. 

This peak season, ask: 

  1. What establishes that the right customer is in control? 
  2. Can a weaker fallback bypass a stronger authentication policy? 
  3. What additional checks apply when identity or device signals change?

This can help prioritize stronger recovery controls. Sending another code should follow an identity decision, rather than substitute for one.

Beyond OTP: What a Better Journey Looks Like

Consider a returning customer using a device with a valid, previously bound cryptographic key.

Instead of automatically sending an SMS code, the business evaluates that key alongside current risk signals. Where confidence meets policy requirements, the customer proceeds without typing a code. Where confidence is insufficient, the business requires additional verification.

Prove Unified Authentication supports this approach by attempting passive authentication, applying fraud policy, and using alternative authentication methods when a key cannot be validated.

The value comes from connecting recognition, authentication, and risk decisions across the journey. Customers don’t have to start from zero at every interaction, and businesses can reserve additional challenges for situations that warrant them.

Start with One Journey

Black Friday should bring more customers through your business. Make sure your authentication strategy helps them get there. 

Start with one journey with high OTP volume and evaluate where passive authentication could reduce routine challenges while maintaining appropriate controls.

Prove's OTP Assessment gives you a starting point, helping you evaluate customer impact, cost exposure, and fraud and operational risk. Answer 7 questions to help you identify where OTP dependence deserves a closer look.

[Take the Prove OTP Assessment →]

‍

The modern
way of proving identity

Trusted by 2,000+ leading companies to reduce fraud and improve consumer

Frequently Asked Questions

How does OTP authentication increase costs during Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

OTP authentication increases costs during Black Friday and Cyber Monday because every SMS code, retry, and failed authentication attempt can generate additional expenses. As shopping traffic increases, businesses may face higher messaging fees, operational costs, and customer support demands. For example, a business processing 10 million authentication journeys monthly, averaging 1.3 OTPs at $0.05 per message, could spend $650,000 per month on OTP delivery alone. Unified authentication can help reduce these costs by recognizing trusted customers and minimizing unnecessary OTP challenges.

Why are SMS OTPs vulnerable to fraud during peak shopping periods?

SMS one-time passcodes are vulnerable to phishing, SIM swapping, social engineering, and real-time OTP relay attacks. According to NIST, OTP authentication is not phishing-resistant, meaning attackers may obtain or intercept valid codes without being the legitimate account holder. During Black Friday and Cyber Monday, high transaction volumes and increased fraud attempts can amplify these risks. Organizations can strengthen security through cryptographically anchored, key-based authentication, persistent authentication, and risk-based step-up verification.

How can businesses reduce OTP authentication costs without increasing fraud or customer friction?

Businesses can reduce OTP authentication costs by adopting unified authentication strategies that recognize trusted returning customers and apply additional verification only when risk warrants it. Persistent authentication helps identify legitimate users across sessions, devices, and lifecycle changes, reducing reliance on SMS codes. Key-based possession and contextual risk signals can strengthen security while minimizing unnecessary interruptions. Organizations can use Prove's OTP Assessment to evaluate their current authentication expenses, identify inefficiencies, and explore opportunities to improve security and customer experience.

Chris Dermody

Keep reading

See all blogs
Read the article: Prove Introduces T-Mobile MVNO Indicator for More Precise Fraud Detection
Blog
Prove Introduces T-Mobile MVNO Indicator for More Precise Fraud Detection

New T-Mobile MVNO Indicator brings greater precision to fraud detection, helping businesses identify risk without introducing unnecessary friction for legitimate customers.

Blog
Read the article: Prove Brings Together Industry Leaders to Tackle Trust Challenges in AI-Driven Payments
Company News
Prove Brings Together Industry Leaders to Tackle Trust Challenges in AI-Driven Payments

TikTok, Velocity, Worldpay and others convene to address emerging risks across identity verification, agentic liability, and the future of payments

Company News
Read the article: Traceable evidence will form the basis of AI agents: Authenticate 2026 speakers
Company News
Traceable evidence will form the basis of AI agents: Authenticate 2026 speakers

Experts from Consult Hyperion, Prove, NIST, iProov identify biometric binding, liveness among key tools

Company News