3 Key Takeaways from Prove's Q1 Fraud & Identity Roundtable

April 3, 2023

Every quarter, Prove gathers industry executives in identity, fraud, and risk to discuss hot topics, key trends in the industry. This is a summary of what we discussed in Q1:

1. Prove Identity™ Prevents Tax Fraud Attack

By establishing a connection between the user attempting to onboard and their phone, Prove protected its clients and consumers from tax and identity fraud.

Bad actors used social engineering and online SMS services to perform an OTP authentication and attempt to file taxes using stolen PII before legitimate taxpayers could file.

  • We stopped the bad actors 🛑 by determining that the phone number used for the fraudster’s OTP did not belong to the PII submitted in the application. 

Prove also identified fraudulent transactions where bad actors recently claimed ownership of the phone number (e.g., less than 90 days before the attack).

For further protection, and to avoid the potential fraudulent transactions altogether, clients can replace traditional SMS OTP workflows with next generation authentication services that protect against social engineering, such as Prove’s Mobile Auth possession check that is performed as part of Prove Identity™ solution.

What is Prove’s next security enhancement? We are developing a signal to tag phone numbers associated with online SMS services as being higher risk.

2. SIM Cloning and SS7 Vulnerability Chatter

Fraud experts were alive with chatter about a potential SS7 vulnerability that could lead to SIM Cloning attacks. Our telephony experts dug in to clear up any confusion.

SIM cloning happens when someone creates a duplicate SIM card from an existing one. When deployed correctly, the SS7 protocol (international standard architecture for telephony signals) protects against SIM Cloning. 

  • We did our own research 💡 by contacting US mobile operators and confirmed that there are no known SS7 vulnerabilities that would allow SIM cloning to occur.

During our investigation, Prove identified that “usage forking” is commonly confused with SIM Cloning. Usage forking occurs when a bad actor accesses a phone number via an online portal or paid ‘fraud-as-a-service’ and uses the phone number without the actual owner knowing. 

3. OTPs Are Not Enough 

Prove continues to observe that high-risk transactions secured only by an OTP (SMS or Voice) are vulnerable to attacks. In some cases, bad actors used the same phone number combined with many different sets of stolen PII to try and create accounts. Without using a separate reputation check and phone ownership check as part of the authentication process, it’s tough to identify and prevent fraud. 

We wanted to remind attendees about Prove’s PRO methodology 🔐 and explain why it’s a next generation approach for lowering fraud rates and mitigating risk:

  • Possession: Confirm the phone number being used during a transaction 
  • Reputation: Evaluate real-time signals such as SIM history, porting history, and line type to determine riskiness of a phone number
  • Ownership: Confirm that the owner of a phone number is the person completing the transaction

PRO is a powerful methodology designed to prevent fraud through a layered, secure approach.


The discussion among Prove's industry executives in identity, fraud, and risk highlighted the importance of developing and implementing next-generation authentication services to combat social engineering and fraud attacks. A warm thank you to all of the executives who participated in this critical discussion.

No items found.

Keep reading

See all blogs
How to Defend Against the Rise of SIM Swap Attacks

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) received reports of a significant increase in SIM swap attacks in 2023, and Experian's 2024 scam forecast identified SIM swapping as one of the top threats, emphasizing the need for heightened awareness and preventive measures.

Mary Ann Miller
July 24, 2024
Fraud in the Age of AI: Meet the Shapeshifter

The COVID-19 pandemic not only changed the way we work and live, it also unleashed a wave of fraud unlike anything we've seen before.

Mary Ann Miller
July 18, 2024
Company News
Introducing Prove Link™ – Unlocking the Power of Identity for Any Business

To continue achieving our mission of accelerating trusted interactions on the internet, we’re proud to announce the introduction of the Prove developer self-service platform and the Prove LinkTM SDK. With these tools, it’s now faster and easier for any company to integrate our industry-leading identity technology into its brand operations.

July 16, 2024
Company News