The CEO of ANZ, Shayne Elliott, touched upon an old argument in the FinTech space—disruption vs. collaboration at the recent Sibos conference in Australia.
Initial perceptions of FinTech startups pegged them as standalone disruptors of the financial ecosystem. The consensus within the financial sector is shifting, though, and, as Elliott indicated, there’s a different trend starting to emerge across the board.
The interesting development we’ve seen over the last 18 months or so is a shift to the view that banks will work with FinTech—rather than FinTech replacing banks.
Elliott also emphasized that although FinTech technologies do not necessarily spell the end of banking, they can undoubtedly spell the end of banks that don’t rapidly adapt, which have leaders lacking flexible mindsets or losing sight of their customers’ value.
Recent studies suggest that both factions believe the opportunity in collaboration is perhaps bigger than the opportunity in pure disruption, especially in the era of Open Banking, which is taking hold in Europe and elsewhere around the globe.
Oleg Boyko, Chairman & Founder of Finstar Financial Group (a private equity firm operating in Europe, the US, Asia, Latin America & the CIS), believes that changes in consumer behavior, advances in cloud-based technology, the growing power and availability of mobile devices, and the emergence of data science are challenging the business models of traditional financial institutions. But Boyko also believes partnerships between FinTechs and banks will bring strategic value to both sides—the philosophy of partnership will add strategic value, insight, and management proficiency.
According to Deloitte, financial institutions are far more likely to collaborate than compete with FinTech, with some estimates suggesting that 82% of incumbent financial service providers expect to increase their FinTech partnerships in the next three to five years.
Partnerships can be equally beneficial for both sides:
Smart incumbents realize that they can benefit from the insights and agility of startups, while startups have understood that the scale, reach, stability, and regulatory management of incumbents can be helpful. — Mike Sigal, Co-founder of Upside Partners, a seed-stage investment firm
But not all partnerships are equal, and below, we’ll look at three interesting ways in which banks and FinTechs are partnering up.
This is a common approach where FinTechs license or sell their underlying technology to banks and other financial institutions. Typically, this would be a white label offering where the bank puts its branding on the product to offer an end-to-end solution.
For the bank, it means they do not have to invest in infrastructure or development costs for an in-house solution to offer a wide range of modern and innovative products under their own brand while still keeping complete control over the customer relationship cycle.
FinTech startups, on the other hand, get access to low-cost funding through a trusted partnership while knowing that the regulatory requirements will be taken care of through the bank’s infrastructure.
Jean-Philippe Vergne, Strategy Professor at the University of Western Ontario in Canada, suggests that banks must leverage the technology developed by FinTech startups to compete against big tech by using licensing agreements, acquisitions, partnerships, or direct investment and also stated that currently, FinTechs present more of an opportunity for big banks than a threat.
OnDeck has a partnership with JPMorgan Chase, and they recently created a wholly-owned subsidiary ODX to provide technology and other services to banks. Other examples include Currencycloud and Fidor Bank, Burling Bank and Akouba, and Kabbage, which has partnered with a number of financial institutions, including Mastercard, Scotiabank, and ING.
This is an especially interesting approach—as it would almost seem counterintuitive—where banks refer clients to relevant FinTechs to plug the gaps in their service offerings. But it is also a process that can help billions of unbanked and underserved individuals globally to get access to better financial service offerings.
It is particularly common in the lending sector, where FinTechs are typically able to offer quicker customer onboarding, faster processing & approval times, cheaper loans, and more alternative methods of funding & lines of credit.
Payvision, a global acquiring network connecting banks, PSPs, ISOs, and their global merchants to simplify cross-border e-commerce through a single payment processing platform, formed a strategic partnership with a multinational Dutch bank ING in January 2018. According to Gijs op de Weegh, COO at Payvision, “FinTech companies and banks can solve the market and consumer challenges together, not replacing one another. They need to complement each other to create more efficient products.”
As a result, the referral approach can take one of three directions:
For banks, there are a number of benefits to the referral approach. They improve the customer experience by plugging product gaps with outsourced FinTech services, which will help retain the customer relationship. Referral fees can also be an additional source of revenue.
FinTech platforms can benefit from a constant stream of business, and therefore, revenue, through a bank’s loyal customer base. This can be vital for survival, especially for young startups.
One example here is WSFS Bank that uses LendKey’s platform to originate student loans.
In the UK, it is actually mandatory for banks to refer business customers who they are unable to serve with loans to alternative providers. The British Business Bank, for example, provides a number of referral programs, including Funding Options, Funding XChange, and Business Finance Compared, for customers to shop around in order to get the best deal.
The more traditional approach would be for banks to purchase the rights to the technology or buy out the company as a whole. But contrary to popular belief, this is not very common, and acquisition activity has only picked up recently. According to a survey by London law firm Simmons & Simmons, 31% of banks and asset managers were expected to fully acquire a FinTech startup in 2018.
The benefit for banks is, of course, that they get exclusive rights to the technology that could give them a competitive edge, rapid expansion into new markets, and a new customer base.
For FinTechs, merging under an established bank’s ecosystem means access to additional funding for the further development of products and hands-on financial market expertise to guide product launches. It could also be a profitable option for founders looking to exit the market while making sure existing customers still benefit from products and services.
Examples of top banks acquiring startups include BBVA (Simple, OpenPay, Madiva), Goldman Sachs (Finance It, Final, Honest Dollar), BNP Paribas (Compte Nickel, Gambit), and JP Morgan Chase (MCX, WePay).
The view that FinTechs exist purely to disrupt and compete against banks and other traditional financial institutions is a stereotypical and outdated one of this young industry’s existence. Granted, as we’ve seen, not all partnerships are created equal, but collaboration, in whichever form, is clearly more beneficial to both sides for future long-term growth, including customer satisfaction and retention.
The share of FinTechs with B2B offerings has increased from 34% in 2011 to almost 50% in 2016. Why is this significant? It means that startups are slowly moving away from purely providing B2C products (i.e., disruption) to partnering and offering products or services to established banks who continue to control the relationship with the end customer. In corporate and investment banking, B2B FinTech offerings are as high as 66%. Estimates also suggest that less than 12% of FinTechs are actually aiming for disruption and the disintermediation of client relationships.
Therefore, the FinTech industry is not one out to try and cause pure disruption and division in traditional financial services. A more accurate view is one of an industry looking to plug the gap in the service offerings of banks to ultimately provide a better customer experience by creating innovative and more inclusive products and services.
Boyko and Rob Morgan of the American Bankers Association (ABA) both agree that, in the end, what matters most is the customer experience, with Morgan noting, “When banks and FinTechs pair together, you get the best of both worlds and customers can get the new innovative services they crave from a trusted partner.”
“Big Data, artificial intelligence, complex algorithms, mobile, and cloud computing, AdTech—it is all combining to create a revolution in the financial services sector. After this revolution, financial services will be available to far more people than currently, in many more markets, be more affordable, be far better tailored to the individual consumer, and be an infinitely better, smoother, more convenient experience for customers.” — Oleg Boyko, Finstar
To learn more about Prove’s Identity solutions and how to accelerate revenue while mitigating fraud, schedule a demo today.
Join 1,000+ companies and 500 banks, including 9 of the top 10 US financial institutions, that are already using Prove to accelerate revenue, mitigate fraud, and enhance customer experience. Contact us today.
Contact us to learn how leading companies are using Prove Pre-fill to modernize the account creation process by shaving off clicks and keystrokes that kill conversion.
Get in touch to find out how we can help you identify your customers at every stage of their journey and offer them seamless and secure experiences.
Let our expert team guide you through our identity verification and authentication solutions. Select a date and time that works for you.
Find out how we can help you deliver seamless and secure customer experiences that comply with PSD2/SCA. Select a date and time that works for you.